Sam Mason, CND Council member and trade union campaigner, explains why CND is marking the 50th anniversary of the Lucas Plan.
In the Autumn Statement, Chancellor John Healey reiterated the Government’s commitment to increased defence spending to ‘keep Britain safe’ and drive economic growth. The reality of this is a drive to war with more public money for the arms companies, supported by the proliferation of AI technology and data centres.
Above all, this does little to keep us safe from catastrophic climate change, job insecurity, the cost-of-living crisis, and crumbling public services. In other words, real human security.
This has parallels with the economic and energy crises of the 1970s – the times in which the Lucas Aerospace shop stewards combine developed their Alternative Corporate Plan. With its emphasis on socially useful production and popular planning, its 50th Anniversary this year is a timely reminder that another way is possible.
The Lucas Plan story started as a trade union fight against restructuring and job cuts as the profits of this large multinational company took a downturn in the face of new global competition and technological change. Over half of Lucas’ aerospace contracts served military contracts dependent on public financing.
Central to the restructuring was a ‘rationalisation’ programme which included the introduction of new technology and what was known as the Frederick Winslow Taylor ‘scientific management’ model. This meant the monitoring of workers through ‘time and motion’ to improve efficiency and deskilling of workers through the automation of production. This is a ‘politics of technology’ which abstracts workers skills and knowledge to be embodied in machinery and systems of organisation, eventually eliminating labour and is no more starkly seen today as perhaps its ultimate end game of AI.
The Lucas Aerospace workers understood a different response was needed to fight job losses and the emerging capital intensive technology. Uniting across the various Lucas Aerospace sites, they formed a shop stewards combine to represent workers across the company. Encouraged by the then Secretary of State for Industry, Tony Benn, to produce an alternative plan, the Combine reasoned that if their jobs could no longer be guaranteed, then state support should be used to support diversification and invest in products society needed, rather than paying workers to be redundant.
Conducting a survey across all the plants for alternative products, the shops stewards combine came up with a list of 150 product ideas. These included heat pumps, wind turbines, rail-road transport and kidney dialysis machines. The latter was already being produced on one of the sites, but the Lucas management ultimately rejected the plan and refused to diversify.
The Lucas Plan has often been cited as a failure as it was never implemented. One reason for this was that it lacked support across the labour movement and was a threat to its own power structures. At the time, even the Financial Times conceded that the Lucas Plan was ‘one of the most radical alternative plans ever drawn up by workers for their company’.
As peace, anti-nuclear, trade union, environmental and climate change activists, it has been the foundation of our demand for defence diversification for peaceful, socially and ecologically useful production.
It is this enduring legacy that underpins why we are celebrating the 50th anniversary of the Alternative Lucas Corporate Plan at the University of Manchester on 21st November. But this event is not about nostalgia. The threat of war including nuclear war, AI, and climate change has made a new Lucas Plan even more necessary today. This means an economy-wide plan using workers’ skills and knowledge developed from the ‘bottom-up’ within communities, trade unions, the peace, environmental and climate movements among others.
As the former Lucas Plan shop stewards combine member Brian Salisbury says, the Lucas Plan 50th anniversary event is determined to “help build a new movement for socially useful production. That means policies and products that overcome the problems of inequality, poverty, environmental destruction and conflict created by the last 50 years of neoliberalism.”
CND, including Greater Manchester CND, is formerly supporting the Lucas Plan event. Our general secretary Sophie Bolt will be speaking in the workshop ‘Defence Diversification: transition from armaments to green industrial strategy’ where the Alternative Defence Review provides an important contribution to a new movement for socially useful production.
The Lucas plan is an idea whose time must come.